Selecting A Cartridge

A crash course on where to start your search for your next rifle.

 
 

Step One: What Are Your Shooting and at what range?

The first step into deciding which cartridge to pick, is deciding what you are shooting, and the expected ranges you will be shooting it at. Below are the recommended minimum energy levels a projectile should have on impacting various big game animals. Energy levels are only a rough guideline to get you into the right ball park, and should never be used to determine if a bullet should be used in a specific role. Terminal ballistics performance is the result of the construction of the bullet, not simply how heavy it is and how fast it is going. If impact happens at extremely high velocity, an improperly selected bullet can “detonate”, fragmenting into small pieces of lead and copper, all of which lack the energy needed to penetrate muscle and bone. To visualize this, imagine a bullet impacting with 3000 ft-lbs of energy, then disintegrating into 3000 pieces, all of which now only have 1 ft-lbs of energy, or throwing a 500 gram rock at a window vs throwing 500 grams of sand. The opposite is also true for impact velocities that are too low. A bullet will fail to deform on meeting tissue, and simply push through without causing a hydraulic shockwave (a “bang flop” is the result of the hydraulic shockwave traveling up the ribs, spine, and to the brain, knocking an animal unconscious while it bleeds out) or produce a wide wound channel. To visualize this, imagine shooting an arrow with a field point.

Moose-2500 ft-lbs

Elk-2000 ft-lbs

Deer-1500 ft-lbs


Step Two: Pick A Bore

6mm (.243win)

At A Glance: Fast muzzle velocities in a very low recoiling package, make most 6mm rifles very comfortable to shoot and quite forgiving within most hunting ranges encountered. They Generally lack hunting energy at longer ranges however.

Suggested For: Deer 300m and under, long range coyote rifle.

Weight Ranges: 70-115 grains

Energy Ranges: 2100-800 ft-lbs

 

6.5mm (6.5x55, 6.5Creedmor, 260Rem, 6.5-300SAUM, 6.5x.284, .264WinMag)

At A Glace: High Ballistic coefficients result in very flat trajectories, very manageable recoil, and efficiently takes energy downrange. Most 6.5mm cartridges are very capable at longer range shots on deer and perform very well at the range.

Suggested For: Deer and long range target shooting. In Europe, 6.5x55 is very commonly used to kill moose.

Weight Ranges: 120-140 grains

Energy Ranges: 2900-1200 ft-lbs

 

7mm (7mmRemMag, 7mm-08, .280Rem, 7mmWSM, 7-300WSM)

At A Glace: When firing a bullet of the same weight, these 7mm cartridges will carry energy downrange better then a .30cal/7.62mm thanks to a higher ballistic coefficient.

Suggested For: Long range deer hunting, elk and moose hunting with discretion to projectile construction.

Weight Ranges: 140-170 grains

Energy Ranges: 3400-1300 ft-lbs

 

7.62mm/.30 caliber (30-30, .308Win, 30-06, .300WSM, .300WM, .300RUM)

At A Glace: The general-purpose workhouse of most hunting camps, these cartridges are able to provide more energy then 7mm cousins for heavy game like elk and moose. Most cartridges in this ballpark have a moderate to high recoil, but are more forgiving to poor shot placement. They rely more on weight then speed to get their energy, and as a result make excellent shorter range bush rifles, and can be easy on meat.

Suggested For: All big game hunting applications. Short range bush rifles, long range big game hunting for all species

Weight Ranges: 150-210 grains

Energy Ranges: 4100-1000 ft-lbs

 

.338(.338 Lapua Mag, .338 Win Mag, .338 Federal)

At A Glace: Excellent long range performance from large case magnums like the .338 Laupa are the ultimate in long range hunting. Such rifles are typically heavy and expensive however. Smaller cases such as the .338 Federal are extremely efficient, high knockdown killers within hunting ranges.

Suggested For: Long range hunting applications, short and intermediate range hunting applications requiring fast knockdown, such as small pieces of private property, or dangerous game.

Weight ranges: 200-300 grains

Energy Ranges: 5000-2000 ft-lbs

 

 

.243win, 260rem, 7mm-08, 308win, .338Fed. All of these are varients of the .308Win

.243win, 260rem, 7mm-08, 308win, .338Fed. All of these are varients of the .308Win

 

87 grain 6mm, 115 grain 6mm, 140 grain 6.5mm, 140 grain 7mm, 190 grain 7mm, 155 grain 7.62mm, 210 grain 7.62mm, 300 grain .338. All bullets are Berger VLD Hunting.

 
The WSM family of cartridges

The WSM family of cartridges


30-06 family compared to magnums

30-06 family compared to magnums

Cutaway of a chamber showing throat erosion

Cutaway of a chamber showing throat erosion

Step Three, Select a Case

Selecting a case is by far the most difficult part. A dozen considerations go back a forth and trade characteristics. Somewhere in heaven is a low recoiling, flat shooting cartridge, with enough energy to put down a cape buffalo and also never needs to be re-barreled. Down on earth, we need to give up some things to get others. When picking a case, go through the shelves at Cabela’s or the online catalog of an ammunition manufacture like Hornady or Federal, and compare the energy levels at the ranges you intend on hunting. Ballistic calculators like "Applied Ballistics" are also great at figuring out the performance of each case. Generally, you are going to weigh the following considerations to determine which cartridge is ideal for you application

Velocity

Velocity = Forgiveness. The faster a projectile moves through the air, the less time gravity and environmental factors have to act on it. A bullet leaving the barrel faster will fly in a flatter arc, then that same bullet leaving the rifle slower. These things together mean a faster bullet is more “forgiving” for errors made in range to target, high angle, and many others.

Picks for Velocity: .243Win, 6.5x284, 7mmSAUM, .300WinMag, .338LapuaMag

Barrel Life

A common guideline for determining expected barrel life is “overbore”. Overbore is the relationship between bore diameter and case capacity. A smaller bore, with more powder, burns out faster. The .308 Winchester family of cartridges demonstrates this perfectly as the .243Win, .260Rem, 7mm-08, .308Win, and .338 Federal, all use the same case. The .243 is a notorious barrel burner, with many competitive shooters rebarreling after only 1100 or fewer shots. The .308 Winchester is known to maintain accuracy for 3500 shots or more. Both cartridges have basically the same amount of powder capacity, however the .243 fires a lighter, smaller bullet, nearly 900fps faster then the .308 Winchester. This means it is more forgiving, and easier to shoot, but the cost of that ballistic performance is shorter barrel life and reduced energy.

Picks for Barrel Life: 6x45(also called 6x.223), 6.5Grendel, 7mm-08, 7.62x39, .308Win

Recoil

Recoil is the price that is paid for more velocity and energy and the easiest way to quantify recoil is by looking at muzzle energy. In rifles that weigh the same, muzzle energy is relative to recoil felt. A heavier rifle has more of a “push”, as it takes more energy and time for a heavy rifle to accelerate rearward (and slower to decelerate in your shoulder). A lighter rifle will feel more like a “punch”. If firing in large volumes, heavy recoil can cause the development of a “flinch” and also causes “shooter fatigue” rapidly.

Picks for Recoil: .243Win, 7mm-08, 7.62x39

Availability and Cost

A large number of special “wildcat” cartridges are out there, and after playing around with standard cartridges, you may start to see the appeal of having a completely custom rifle with a chambering, that is perfectly tailored to your size, weight, and needs.  While these “wildcats” often have amazing performance potential and can fill a role perfectly, the sacrifice is never being able to head into Walmart on the way out of town to pick up a box of shells. The .308 Winchester, 30-06 and others can be found in in back water gas stations, across Canada and the USA. Picking a mass-produced cartridge also reduces the cost of shooting greatly and I generally suggest new shooters or those on a budget look into .308Win because of this. The most accurate rifle ever built would not be any more useful then an SKS to someone who could only afford to shoot a single box of ammo a year.

Picks for Affordability: .223Rem, .308Win, 7.62x39

Picks for Availability: .243Win, .308Win, 30-06, .300WinMag, 7mmRemMag

****For first time rifle buyers, I Strongly suggest picking one from this list (Avaiability), a VERY wide selection of affordable factory ammunition will mean you can tailor your load for a wide range of different applications from moose to target practice*****